Constructing the Invisible City with Nanelle Jayawardene - 421 Arts Campus
At 421 Arts Campus
24th October 2026

Field notes from Mina Zayed
On 24 October, a group of like-minded individuals, entirely unknown to one another, assembled in the shed at 421 Arts Campus. There is something worth noting even in that first condition: through contemporary event-registration technologies, a collection of strangers had independently chosen to arrive in the same room at the same time, already bound by a shared curiosity before any conversation had taken place. 421 were diligent and conscientious hosts. The studio had been prepared carefully, materials laid out, transport organised, and the table was quite literally set for an exchange.
Constructing an Invisible City began from a simple proposition: public spaces are often judged by the quality of their visible infrastructure, yet architecture alone does not determine how people choose to inhabit them. The workshop was an attempt to look instead for the less visible city: the habits, negotiations, permissions, inhibitions and small acts of appropriation through which people make architecture social.
We began, however, with people rather than places. After introducing myself and my practice, setting out the plan for the day, and distributing a fieldwork pamphlet I had designed for the workshop, each participant drew a fictional persona. There was an immediate and unexpected amount of affection for these invented people. We read them out, compared them and gushed over whom we had each drawn. Before leaving 421, everyone wrote the name of their persona alongside their own in the pamphlet. We then worked through a deliberately simple set of prompts: I would if I could. I do. I would never. We answered these first as ourselves and then again through the persona we had been assigned, considering a series of ordinary activities and behaviours in public space.
The exercise established a premise that would become increasingly important throughout the day: there is no universal urban subject. The same place presents different possibilities to different people. What one person reads as invitation, another may read as exposure. What one person considers comfortable, another may avoid entirely. Age, familiarity, occupation, confidence, dress, companionship and perceived permission all alter the field of what appears possible.
After a short coffee break, we boarded the bus provided by 421 for the five-minute journey to Mina Zayed. There were already several different understandings of Mina Zayed among us. For some, it was their first visit to the markets. Others were regular visitors and had favourite shops. Some approached the exercise as would-be urban sleuths. But all were, in one way or another, architectural thinkers: people attentive to their urbanity and to the conditions through which city life is produced.
With our pamphlets open to the maps, we began recording the human life interplaying with the form of the market. The purpose was not to survey the architecture as a static object. It was to pay attention to the relationship between built form and lived behaviour: where people stopped, where they sat and lingered, which edges became occupied, where workers gathered, where customers hesitated, which spaces appeared private despite being physically exposed, what had been appropriated, what had been added, and which small environmental or spatial conditions seemed to make one place more inhabitable than another. The intention was to look for the city that would not ordinarily appear on an architectural plan.
Field note 01: the first date market row
We began along the first row of date shops facing the butchery. The first condition that became apparent was architectural. The canopies or verandas on this side are considerably deeper than those in the consecutive alleys. There is an odd spatial effect here. It feels almost as though the walls, internal partitions and entire setting-out of the building had shifted away into the next alley after the roof and floor slabs had already been constructed. The roof remains where one expects the building to be, while the enclosed shopfronts appear to have retreated beneath it. The result is an unusually deep zone between shop and street.
One might therefore expect this to be the most comfortable of the market streets. Yet this alley felt extremely hot, noticeably more so than the streets that followed. This was already useful. The simple architectural assumption that deeper shade automatically produces greater comfort did not adequately explain the lived condition.
The street is also deeply entangled with the tourist economy. Large tourist buses regularly arrive at the rear of this row. At the point where As Sadaf Street meets the perpendicular street, also somewhat unhelpfully named As Sadaf Street, there is a popular drop-off point for coaches, releasing groups of visitors almost directly into the date shops. Several shopkeepers told us that tourists constitute the majority of their trade. The spatial organisation of the market therefore cannot be understood only through its immediate local context. It is connected to hotel itineraries, tour operators, coach routes and international tourism networks.
That relationship has become increasingly precarious. Shopkeepers spoke about the impact of the current regional political situation on visitor numbers. We were told that tourism had fallen to approximately thirty per cent of what it had previously been. Whatever the precise proportion, the consequences were evident in the concern expressed by those whose businesses depend heavily on these arrivals. One cannot help wondering what this means for the future of some of these shops. This was particularly striking because, architecturally, very little appeared to have changed. The shops remained open, the verandas remained and the coach drop-off remained, yet the economic and social life sustaining the street had become significantly more fragile.
Another spatial pattern became visible as we moved along the row. Some of the shops are through-shops, extending from one market street to the other. Tourists appeared particularly drawn to these. The ability to see or sense another exit perhaps makes the shop easier to enter; one is not committing to an enclosed interior but moving through what feels more like a continuation of the street.
There was also a much more immediate attraction: air-conditioning. The promise of a cooler interior could strongly influence which shop someone entered. An open or slightly ajar door, the sensation of cold air escaping into the veranda, or simply the visible suggestion that one space was air-conditioned more effectively than another could alter pedestrian behaviour. Two neighbouring shops might be almost identical in size, appearance and merchandise, yet one small environmental cue could produce a very different pattern of occupation. Comfort itself had become a form of invitation.
The architecture of the street was therefore being supplemented by signals that would never appear in its formal description: an open door, a trace of cool air, the visibility of another exit, the expectation of shade. These were small things, but they mattered.
Field note 02: turning the corner
We turned at the junction where As Sadaf meets As Sadaf and entered the next street. Almost immediately, the environmental condition changed. This alley felt relatively cooler. The verandas here are dramatically narrower, only a couple of feet deep in places, barely enough to accommodate a worker’s chair outside a shop. Again, the geometry reinforced the impression that the entire market block had somehow been shifted towards this street after the larger roof structure had already been established. The generous depth experienced on the opposite side had produced a compressed condition here.
Yet this narrower street had acquired another advantage. The next block sits considerably closer than the butchery does to the first market row. The distance is sufficiently narrow for fabric canopies to be stretched between the two buildings, and this possibility has been used extensively. The fabric shades create a more continuous field of protection across the street and appear to make this alley particularly desirable for car and motorcycle owners. Vehicles are parked wherever the greatest degree of shade can be obtained.
This, in turn, creates another spatial condition. A yellow, slanted concrete kerb forms a clear boundary between the veranda and the vehicular zone. Along this line sit large SUVs, cars and motorcycles. The taller vehicles in particular create an unexpectedly strong edge. They become almost architectural. A row of parked SUVs forms a visual barrier between the narrow veranda and the street. Behind this line of cars, the veranda begins to acquire a much more domestic quality. The worker sitting outside the shop is partially screened from traffic and from the wider street, enclosed not by a wall designed by an architect but by parked vehicles. The car becomes edge, screen and enclosure.
This was one of the more interesting inversions of the morning. The vehicle, so often understood as an obstruction to public life, was simultaneously producing a degree of privacy and spatial definition for the people occupying the veranda.
There were also noticeably more movable chairs in this alley than in the previous one, yet despite the greater number of chairs the verandas felt less social. Their narrowness allowed a person to sit, but offered little room for several bodies to gather comfortably or to turn towards one another. The atmosphere was quieter and more individual. Rather than feeling like a communal public edge, the veranda resembled a sequence of very small domestic territories attached to individual shops.
We were then told that the number of chairs outside each business is regulated by the municipality. The allowance, we understood, is effectively one chair per shop. Suddenly the furniture itself became more legible. There were many wheelable ex-office chairs, generally positioned singly outside the shops, alongside stacks of plastic chairs stored rather than continuously deployed. The difference between a single chair and a stack of chairs began to feel significant. The first could remain within the visible allowance. The latter suggested latent social capacity: additional occupation stored vertically until required or permitted.
A municipal regulation intended to organise the public realm had become materially visible in the everyday furniture of the market. It was another reminder that social space is never produced by architecture alone. It is simultaneously shaped by regulation, interpretation, enforcement and the small accommodations through which people continue to make themselves comfortable within those rules.
Field note 03: towards the fruit and vegetable market
The next street leads towards the fruit and vegetable market. Again, the atmosphere changed. Of the streets we had walked through, this felt the coolest. There was a clear movement of air coming through from the direction of the fish dock and waterfront, and the breeze immediately altered the experience of the space.
But the same openness that produced ventilation also made the street feel more exposed. Here, the parked cars did not create the same continuous, immovable edge that they had formed in the previous alley. Without that line of large vehicles, the veranda appeared more directly connected to the street. Yet another set of objects had begun performing the work of spatial definition.
Produce crates and shelving occupied the fronts of the shops. Boxes, displays and storage elements extended into the veranda. These objects subdivided what would otherwise have been a large and ambiguous covered zone into smaller territories. The crates were not simply holding fruit and vegetables. They were producing space. They interrupted long sightlines, formed partial edges, created pockets of enclosure and broke the veranda down into smaller, more domestic and inhabitable areas.
The verandas here were deep again, but their occupation felt markedly different from those of the first date-market row. There was much more visible evidence of everyday life and agency. Coffee and tea-making stations had appeared, alongside water jugs, fans, personal belongings, improvised storage and small pieces of furniture. Here we found the greatest collection of eclectic chairs. The furniture appeared accumulated rather than designed: office chairs, plastic chairs, stools and other seats that had presumably arrived because they were available, comfortable or useful.
These small objects made the working lives behind the market frontage perceptible. This was no longer simply a commercial interface between customer and shop. It was also somewhere people spent hours of their day. The addition of a kettle, a fan or a chair changes the interpretation of the veranda. These objects announce duration. Someone expects to remain here. They also indicate agency. The shopkeeper or worker has altered the environment in response to heat, fatigue, thirst, sociability and habit. Architecture had provided a broad roof and floor. Everyday life had produced the room.
By this point the three streets had begun to operate almost like an accidental comparative study. They belonged to the same market, shared a largely continuous architectural language and sat only metres apart, yet each supported a different social condition. The first date-market street contained deep verandas but remained extremely hot. Its occupation was strongly tied to coach tourism, through-shops and the promise of air-conditioned interiors. The second street had extremely narrow verandas but benefited from fabric shade stretched between neighbouring blocks. Cars congregated beneath that shelter and, in turn, became a hard visual edge that produced quieter, more private, almost domestic spaces behind them. The third street was cooled by air movement from the waterfront. It was more exposed, but produce crates, shelving and everyday objects fragmented the deep veranda into smaller territories of occupation. Here the accumulated signs of daily life were most visible.
None of these conditions could be adequately understood from a plan. The plan would show the walls. It might show the canopy depth and the kerb. It would not show that an SUV becomes a wall, that a stack of crates becomes a room, that the promise of air-conditioning becomes an invitation, or that a municipal restriction on chairs alters the morphology of social occupation. It would not show that one alley feels domestic while another feels exposed. Nor would it show that an international political situation could manifest itself as an anxious shopkeeper standing in a quiet date store waiting for a coach that arrives less frequently than it once did.
This was precisely the invisible city we had set out to examine. Not invisible because it could not be seen, but because it is rarely represented.
Field note 04: lunch
Once we had walked the streets and recorded our observations, we moved towards a small lunch spot at the back of the market, a place where many of the workers usually eat. By then, everyone needed to cool down. We sat together over an off-menu South Indian thali.
The pause was useful. We had spent the morning recording other people’s occupation of space, but now found ourselves inhabiting one of the market’s everyday spaces of retreat. We ate where workers ate, cooled down, compared maps and exchanged observations. We began to notice what others had noticed and we had missed. In that sense, lunch was not entirely separate from the fieldwork. It became another way of entering the rhythms of the market, however temporarily.
By this point, the distinction between architectural form and social life had become increasingly difficult to draw cleanly. A canopy was not only shelter; it was commercial territory, thermal condition and potential social room. A parked car was not only a vehicle; it was an edge. A crate was not only storage; it was subdivision. A chair was not simply furniture; it was rest, regulation, territorial claim and possibility. An open door was not only an entrance; it was an environmental signal. An alley was not merely circulation. It could simultaneously be workplace, frontage, waiting room, parking zone, tourist route and domestic threshold.
A market that appeared relatively stable as built form could therefore be changing profoundly through shifts in tourism, regulation, climate, economic circumstance and everyday patterns of occupation.
Field note 05: the chair in the new market
After lunch, we climbed back onto the bus and continued to Fisherman’s Wharf, where we caught a glimpse of the new market development that is due to accommodate stores from the older markets we had just spent the morning walking through.
Our conversation centred almost immediately on an object that had become increasingly important over the course of the morning: where would the worker’s chair go?
It was a deliberately small question, but it contained several larger ones. How might workers exert their own agency within these new spaces? Where might the kettle, fan, water jug or stack of plastic chairs find a place? How might the individual identity of one shop distinguish itself from the next? What happens to the accumulated signs of occupation when the architectural envelope is already highly articulated?
The new development presents a much more detailed and formally resolved exterior. That resolution inevitably raises questions about what remains available for inhabitants to complete themselves. In the older market, much of the character of a shop is communicated through occupation. Furniture moves outside. Produce spills forward. Crates reorganise the veranda. Doors remain open. Workers establish small territories of rest and sociability. Objects accumulate over time. The storefront is not a finished composition; it is continually being made.
Looking towards the new development, our question was not whether the architecture was good or bad, nor whether the new facilities would provide improvements in comfort or infrastructure. It was more specific: where, within a more predetermined architectural language, will the evidence of individual agency appear? How much visual and spatial room remains for the shopkeeper to make the place recognisably theirs? Could the new architecture accommodate the informal adjustments through which the old market had become inhabited, or would those adjustments begin to appear as disorder against a more carefully controlled image?
The worker’s chair had become a useful measure. It was no longer simply somewhere to sit. It represented the ability of an individual to modify a piece of city around the requirements of everyday life.
Returning to 421
We returned to 421 for further discussion and for the considerable relief of air-conditioning. By this point there were around twenty-two of us moving through the day together. Back in the studio, the observations accumulated during the walk could be considered again at a distance. The fieldwork had given us a collection of apparently minor things: chairs, cars, crates, shades, thresholds, doors, breezes, shopfronts, rules, habits and conversations. Taken together, however, they described a city considerably more complex than the one represented through architectural form alone.
The original intention of Constructing an Invisible City was to use these observations as the basis from which to imagine different social worlds. Participants had begun the morning inhabiting fictional personas, asking what each might do, refuse, desire or feel permitted to attempt. Mina Zayed then supplied the evidence of how those kinds of individual negotiations already occur within the existing city.
The exercise was never really about redesigning the market. It was about recognising that changing the assumptions, behaviours, customs and permissions of the people occupying the same architecture could produce an entirely different city.
The workshop that did not quite end
The advertised workshop eventually came to an end. The gathering did not.
We overstayed at 421, talking and continuing conversations begun during the walk. A number of us then wandered together through MiZa. We visited MAKE, where one of the workshop participants generously gave us a full tour of her studio. From there, the group continued on to Mina Creamery. By the time the day actually dispersed, it was approximately two and a half hours beyond the advertised finish time.
This was not planned, and perhaps it became the most useful unplanned observation of the day. Around twenty-two people, most of whom had been entirely unknown to one another that morning, had spent several hours walking, looking, mapping, eating, questioning and exchanging observations. By the nominal end of the workshop, there was no particular reason for them to remain together. Yet they did.
The movement from 421 to Mina Zayed, from market to lunch table, from Fisherman’s Wharf back to the studio, and eventually out again through MiZa, MAKE and Mina Creamery had gradually produced something that could not have been programmed directly: a temporary community.
Its continuation has been equally interesting. Several participants have remained in contact. Some have subsequently attended other events of mine. Conversations have continued elsewhere. One weekend, another participant and I ended up playing padel together. These are modest outcomes, but perhaps that is precisely why they matter.
The workshop set out to examine the invisible negotiations through which people transform physical space into social space. By the end of the day, the workshop itself had become an example. The original infrastructure had been straightforward: an event listing, a registration platform, a prepared studio, a pamphlet, a bus, an itinerary and a set of activities. Those things created the conditions for gathering. They did not, by themselves, create the relationships that followed.
Those emerged through walking beside one another, being hot together, noticing different things, comparing observations, sharing lunch, entering conversations without knowing quite where they would lead, and repeatedly deciding to remain when leaving would have been perfectly reasonable. The programmed event ended long before the social life it produced did.
Looking back, the day reinforced why I remain interested in the relationship between form and life. Architecture matters enormously. The depth of a veranda matters. The distance between buildings matters. Shade matters. Wind matters. The placement of a kerb matters. But none of these things possesses a fixed social consequence. The deep veranda may be hotter than the narrow one. The parked car may create privacy. The municipal regulation may produce a stack of chairs. The crate may become a partition. The open door may become an invitation. The elaborately designed frontage may leave less room for identity than the unresolved one.
What architecture provides is a set of conditions, affordances, constraints and possibilities. What happens next depends upon people and the countless adjustments through which they inhabit those conditions. They adapt, appropriate, negotiate, comply, ignore, improvise, linger, withdraw and gather. The city produced through these actions exists alongside the visible city of buildings, roads and infrastructure. It is not less real because it is difficult to draw. It may, in fact, be the city that matters most.
























