top of page

​

​​

Notes from a public lecture at 421 Arts Campus, 5th November 2026

​

On 5th November I gave a public lecture at 421 Arts Campus, Abu Dhabi, titled The Anatomy of Gathering. The title began, admittedly, with a slightly mischievous premise. Having no medical training of any kind to speak of, the lecture contained no attempt to connect the spleen to the public realm. But “anatomy” felt more appropriate than, say a word like taxonomy. I was less interested in classifying or codifying gatherings than in asking what might be happening inside them: what holds them together, what gives them energy, where their edges lie, what circulates through them, and what causes them eventually to dissolve.

 

These questions sit somewhere between my work as an artist, architect and urban researcher. Across those practices, I keep returning to the relationship between form and life. Architecture is comparatively easy to represent - we can draw it, measure it, photograph it and control it. In contrast, ‘life’ is much harder to deal with, discuss and articulate. Yet it is only through the interplay between life and form, not just form, that cities, buildings, cultural institutions and public spaces become meaningful. This was the starting point of the lecture: before we talk about placemaking, activation or programming, perhaps we need to understand more precisely what kind of social life we are hoping to make possible.

 

A busy place is not necessarily a social place. People can occupy the same room, pavement or public square without forming any meaningful relationship to one another. Ten strangers waiting for a lift are physically close, but they are not necessarily gathered. If the lift breaks down, however, somebody makes a joke, another person may respond, information may begin to circulate and together they decide what to do, the social condition has changed. Proximity has now suddenly become relational.

 

That distinction became one of the central propositions of the evening. A gathering is not simply the presence of many people. It begins when attention, feeling, purpose or action starts to pass between them, and when people become conscious not only that they are experiencing something together. And that as a group, people realise that they are unique in experiencing this moment/event, a temporary “we” appears. That “we” may be fleeting, but it is extraordinarily consequential. It can amplify emotion, make private convictions publicly visible, produce belonging, solidarity, ritual and collective imagination. Indeed, it can also produce exclusion, conformity, coercion and violence. The mechanism itself is not moral.

 

Much of the lecture therefore asked why human beings have repeatedly sought these conditions throughout history. Gathering is not a decorative addition to human society; humans evolved as an unusually interdependent species. There is an evolutionary reason why we needed the collective: survival required collective care, protection, knowledge, trust and the transmission of skills. However, repeated gathering also made memory and culture, collective. Stories could pass between generations, behaviour could be observed, reputation made visible, alliances formed and identities rehearsed. Yet, its even more fascinatingly reassuring that across very different civilisations we repeatedly find the same typologies of gatherings: the feast, the market, religious ceremony, funeral, wedding, theatre, festival, sporting event and political assembly. They are different in purpose, but each allows people to receive and transmit a world that no individual could sustain alone. 

 

While that is one reason why gatherings are a powerful tool of life, the persistence of physical gathering remains interesting precisely because technology has made so many of its survival and informational functions unnecessary. Almost everything I said during the lecture could have been sent as text or streamed online. But people still travelled to 421, crossed a threshold, sat in a room and experienced it alongside strangers. Because, I argued, that there is a difference between simply knowing that other people share an experience with you and actually physically witnessing them sharing it. I can watch a football match alone knowing that millions of people are watching too, but inside a stadium, their reactions become part of my own experience. I am not simply receiving the match; I am receiving everyone else receiving it. The result is a transcending, almost religious experience.

 

This brought the lecture towards Émile Durkheim, Victor Turner and Mikhail Bakhtin, three thinkers who approach collective experience in very different ways. Durkheim’s idea of collective effervescence helps explain the intensification that can occur when people act, attend and respond together. Bodies fall into a kind of rhythm, that engenders a temporary collective biology. Laughter becomes more contagious. A crowd applauds, chants, marches, mourns or becomes silent together. Emotion is no longer produced entirely within the individual because the reactions of others continually return to us as information, that validates our own emotions, thus allowing us to heighten our emotions and responses.

 

Turner is interested in a different possibility: that gatherings can temporarily loosen the classifications and hierarchies through which ordinary life is organised. For a period, familiar roles may become less decisive and another kind of social relationship becomes possible. Bakhtin’s writing on medieval and Renaissance carnival takes this further still. Carnival allows a temporary inversion. In the same way that a fool may mock authority, behaviour ordinarily considered improper becomes permissible, and people who would usually remain socially separated may enter into a more familiar contact. The ordinary world is not permanently abolished, but for a period another one becomes experienceable.

 

This is one reason gathering can be restorative. Ordinary social life requires structure, routine and classification, but those structures can also become rigid and arid if they are not disrupted and returned to. Gatherings offer these periodic interruptions. We leave everyday life, enter a temporarily framed situation and eventually return. What interests me is that the return is rarely complete. A friendship may have formed, an obligation created, a story begun, a grievance intensified, an idea made publicly sayable. The bodies disperse, but something of the temporary collective may survive them.

 

One proposition from the lecture that I continue to return to is that the gathering ends spatially before it ends socially.

 

But the lecture was also an attempt not to romanticise collectivity. Not every form of shared attention creates relation. Domestic gathering, public gathering, accidental gathering and online gathering operate through very different social conditions. A dinner or majlis may offer extraordinary intimacy, continuity and obligation, while public gathering introduces anonymity, difference, visibility and unpredictability. Neither is a deficient version of the other. They simply make different relationships possible.

 

The online gathering posed a more difficult problem. It demonstrates that physical proximity cannot be the only definition of gathering. People can organise, mourn, converse and share attention across enormous distances. Yet the experience is mediated through an apparatus. The camera frames; the screen excludes. We encounter others through selected representations, while simultaneously watching and regulating our own image. There is therefore this undeniable self-alienation that happens in such occasions that lead to inevitable degrees of self-consciousness and performance. This self-alienation sets us up for an intrinsic ‘separateness’ that is intensified by the fact that the online gathering creates the spectacle of the collective, while creating shackles that prevent those who participate in these gatherings from really being absorbed into the collective experience.

 

This led to Guy Debord and the idea of the spectacle. Debord’s argument is not simply that modern life contains too many images. His concern is with a social condition in which representation begins to stand between people and directly lived experience. His critique became useful for thinking not only about digital gatherings but about architecture itself. A space, event or cultural programme can appear intensely social while producing very little social relation. We can become spectators of an image of public life rather than participants in its production.

 

Bertolt Brecht provided an important counterpoint. Brecht was suspicious of the completely absorbed spectator. His theatre sought a form of double consciousness in which one could remain involved while retaining enough distance to recognise that what was being presented had been constructed and could therefore be otherwise. This became a useful question for public life too. Perhaps collective experience requires both capacities: the ability to surrender oneself temporarily to something larger, and enough critical selfhood to observe the thing one has become part of.

 

Architecture participates in this constantly. A stage directs attention; a circle distributes visibility; a balcony allows observation without complete participation; a threshold allows hesitation; a public square permits movement between edge and centre. Spatial organisation does not simply determine how many bodies can fit somewhere; it changes the probability of different social relationships. William H. Whyte’s studies of public space offered perhaps the most grounded way of returning these questions to the city. Whyte watched what people actually did rather than what architects imagined they would do. One of his most useful observations was triangulation: the way a third point of attention can create a relationship between strangers who otherwise have no reason to acknowledge one another. An event, performer, fountain, incident or shared curiosity can become the triangle. People do not necessarily need to begin by being interested in one another. Sometimes they simply need to become interested in something together.

 

That shifts the architectural question considerably. Instead of asking only how to attract people into a place, we might ask what allows people already present to become aware of one another. Density matters, but so do distance, visibility, thresholds, movement, comfort, edges, opportunities to pause and the possibility of joining or withdrawing. Architecture can influence the probability of social contact, but it cannot manufacture the social itself.

 

The lecture ended with Henri Lefebvre’s proposition that social space is socially produced. Space is not an empty vessel waiting for life to be poured into it. Its histories, habits, rituals, rules, economic relationships and repeated occupations become part of what that space is. At the same time, spatial form acts back upon life, making some relationships easier and others more difficult. A wall separates. A bench permits staying. A table creates relation. A threshold allows hesitation. This is where the argument returns to contemporary placemaking and cultural programming. When public space becomes over-formalised, over-surveilled or over-programmed around a predetermined image of sociability, we risk producing the spectacle of public life rather than public life itself. A place can look activated while leaving little room for people to appropriate it, alter it or produce relationships that were not anticipated in advance.

 

Perhaps the most socially productive spaces are therefore not those that most convincingly represent public life, but those that remain sufficiently unfinished for public life to produce itself. Architecture can frame, invite and support. It can create conditions and probabilities. But life must still do the work.

 

Gathering is not simply something that happens inside space.

It is one of the processes through which space becomes social at all.

A gathering also does not end when people have disperse, it can live on in the collective memory through social relations formed, through kinships built, through obligations established, token like photos, leaflets, flags. In a way, this blog post is a way that the gathering we had on the 5th November lives on.

© 2023 by Nanelle Jayawardene

Key words: Architects London, Sri Lanka Architects, Colombo Architects

bottom of page